Skip to content
Back to blog
Trucking

Tale of Two Fleets: How Underwriters Read Your CSA Data Before a Trucking Insurance Renewal

HTHaseeb Tariq · Co-FounderNov 5, 202614 min read
Semi trucks on highway representing the tale of two fleets in the trucking insurance market
Trucking

The commercial trucking insurance market heading into 2027 is becoming a tale of two fleets. Carriers with strong safety records, documented processes, and clean data are seeing flat renewals or modest single-digit increases—and multiple insurer options. Carriers with deteriorating metrics, deferred maintenance, or gaps in driver programs face a different reality: 30-40% rate hikes, fewer markets willing to quote, and in some cases non-renewal. The gap is widening, and underwriters are using data fluency as the filter.

Mark Gallagher, transportation leader at RPS, described this split in Insurance Business: strong fleets are getting flat or roughly 5% renewals and multiple options, while weaker accounts face 30-40% hikes, fewer insurers, and restricted access. Underwriters are asking whether financial pressure is eroding maintenance spending or driver retention. The underlying trend requirement discussed at WSIA sits around 8.5-9%.

Why the market is splitting

Several forces converged to create this two-fleet market. First, loss experience remains elevated. ATRI data shows trucking liability premiums per mile rose 18.6% from 2021 to 2024, while liability losses per mile increased 33.1% over the same period. The III/Milliman forecast puts the US commercial auto net combined ratio at 100.9 for 2026, remaining above 100 through 2028. Insurers cannot continue absorbing these losses uniformly.

Second, operating margins are razor-thin. ATRI reports the average operating cost hit a record $2.336 per mile in 2025, up 3.4%, with repair and maintenance costs climbing 8.6%. Truckload and reefer margins sit below 1%. Insurers at WSIA specifically cited concern that financial pressure is forcing carriers to cut corners—aging equipment without reinvestment, deferred maintenance, reduced driver training spend. Those cuts create the warning signs underwriters now hunt for: rising out-of-service violations, deteriorating safety metrics, and driver turnover.

Third, underwriting tools have improved. Insurers can now pull CSA data, cross-reference maintenance evidence, score telematics feeds, and evaluate driver retention patterns before quoting. The carriers who can present a coherent safety story get capacity. The carriers who show up with only loss runs and hope get filtered out.

Line-level improvement does not mean universal relief

AM Best reported that commercial auto had its best underwriting performance since 2021 in 2025, with mid-year 2026 loss ratio at the lowest in five years. That sounds like good news, and at the line level it is. But improvement in aggregate does not mean every trucking account sees relief.

Insurers are achieving better results by segmenting risk more aggressively—offering competitive terms to strong fleets while non-renewing or significantly surcharging weaker ones. A carrier with excellent metrics contributes to that improved ratio; a carrier with deteriorating metrics is priced out of it. The rising tide is not lifting all boats. It is sorting boats by seaworthiness.

What underwriters actually pull

Before quoting or renewing a trucking account, underwriters assemble a risk profile from multiple sources. Understanding what they see helps carriers prepare what they present.

Data sources underwriters use to evaluate trucking accounts.
SourceWhat Underwriters LearnRed Flags
CSA/SMS BASICsPercentile rankings across seven safety categoriesHigh Unsafe Driving, HOS Compliance, or Vehicle Maintenance percentiles
Out-of-service ratesRoadside enforcement outcomes for driver and vehicleOOS rates above national average, especially vehicle OOS
Loss runsHistorical claim frequency, severity, and litigation outcomesNuclear verdicts, frequency trends, at-fault patterns
Maintenance evidencePM compliance, brake/tire inspection records, shop disciplineGaps in PM schedules, repeated mechanical failures
Driver retention and trainingTurnover rates, onboarding process, ongoing training recordsHigh turnover, no documented training program
Telematics and dashcam dataDriving behavior scores, event review process, coaching documentationEquipment installed but not utilized, no coaching records

Progressive's Peter Niro explained in FreightWaves that premiums are driven by accident likelihood and average claim cost. Dashcams promote safer driving, can enable savings when fleet data is shared with the insurer, and establish facts of loss for claims defense. Niro also noted that premiums can shift mid-policy when operations change—adding drivers, vehicles, or routes alters the risk profile.

The CSA data underwriters see

Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) scores remain a primary input to trucking underwriting. The Safety Measurement System (SMS) calculates percentile rankings across seven Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories (BASICs): Unsafe Driving, Hours-of-Service Compliance, Driver Fitness, Controlled Substances/Alcohol, Vehicle Maintenance, Hazardous Materials Compliance, and Crash Indicator.

High percentiles in Unsafe Driving, Vehicle Maintenance, or HOS Compliance immediately trigger scrutiny. But underwriters also look at the underlying data: inspection frequency, violation types, and trends over time. A carrier with a declining percentile tells a different story than one with a stable or improving trend.

Out-of-service rates matter independently. A driver OOS rate or vehicle OOS rate above the national average suggests enforcement is finding problems on the road—problems the carrier's internal processes failed to catch. Vehicle OOS rates in particular signal maintenance discipline.

Important: the new SMS methodology is not live yet

Some industry sites have reported that new CSA scoring rules are already in effect. This is incorrect. Carriers should prepare without panicking.

According to Trucksafe, FMCSA Chief Safety Officer Steve Dowling said at the WEX OTR Summit on October 28, 2026 that FMCSA will present SMS proposals for industry comment in coming weeks and months. As of early November 2026, the enhanced SMS methodology approved in November 2024 is not live. Carriers are still scored on the seven BASICs under SMS Methodology v3.21. The next SMS update is scheduled for the week of November 9, 2026.

The FMCSA Prioritization Preview describes the approved changes coming: BASICs become 'compliance categories,' Controlled Substances/Alcohol and operating-while-OOS violations move into Unsafe Driving, Vehicle Maintenance splits into Vehicle Maintenance and Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed, severity weights simplify to 1 or 2, and percentiles will only be calculated in some categories if there is a violation in the last 12 months. The Federal Register notice provides the full methodology.

What this means for carriers: the current scoring rules still apply, but the new methodology will change how certain violations are weighted and categorized. Carriers should understand what is coming and begin addressing the behaviors that will be scored differently—particularly driver-observed pre-trip defects, which will feed a new Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed category.

The 90-60-30 day pre-renewal checklist

Carriers should not wait until the renewal packet arrives to prepare their safety story. A structured timeline helps assemble the documentation underwriters will request.

90 days out

  • Pull your current SMS scores and review percentile trends across all BASICs.
  • Run a DataQs review: challenge any inspections with coding errors or incorrect violations.
  • Audit driver qualification files: MVRs, medical cards, training certifications.
  • Review maintenance records: PM compliance rates, brake/tire inspection documentation.
  • Assess telematics utilization: are critical events being reviewed and documented?

60 days out

  • Compile driver scorecards with 12-month trend data.
  • Document coaching records: link events to conversations and driver acknowledgments.
  • Prepare equipment summary: age of fleet, camera coverage, telematics penetration.
  • Review loss runs for accuracy and prepare narrative context for any significant claims.
  • Identify any drivers or units that need to be addressed before renewal.

30 days out

  • Assemble the renewal package: SMS scores, scorecards, coaching samples, training records, maintenance summary.
  • Prepare a one-page safety program overview for underwriters.
  • Brief your broker on any operational changes, new lanes, or fleet additions.
  • Confirm all required documents are current and accessible.

How agencies can present a strong-fleet submission

For insurance agencies writing trucking, the tale of two fleets means the submission quality determines whether an underwriter engages or declines to quote. A stack of ACORD forms and loss runs is no longer sufficient for accounts that need competitive capacity.

  • Lead with the safety story: summarize SMS trends, OOS rates, and any remediation efforts.
  • Include telematics utilization metrics, not just equipment lists.
  • Attach sample coaching documentation to demonstrate process maturity.
  • Provide maintenance evidence: PM compliance rates, brake inspection schedules.
  • Contextualize loss history: explain any outlier claims and what changed afterward.
  • Highlight driver retention and training programs.

The agencies that win capacity for their trucking accounts are the ones that translate carrier operations into the risk language underwriters speak. HaulSure OS is built for this workflow—organizing carrier submissions, tracking risk data, and producing the documentation that differentiates a strong-fleet presentation from a commodity submission.

Preparing for the pending SMS changes

While the new SMS methodology is not yet live, carriers can begin preparing for the changes it will bring. The split of Vehicle Maintenance into two categories—one for roadside-discovered defects and one for driver-observed pre-trip defects—means that pre-trip inspection documentation becomes more important.

  • Review pre-trip inspection processes: are drivers documenting defects, and are those defects being addressed before dispatch?
  • Ensure pre-trip defect records are retained and retrievable.
  • Train drivers on what the new Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed category will capture.
  • Consider how telematics and ELD data can support pre-trip compliance documentation.

The consolidation of Controlled Substances/Alcohol into Unsafe Driving and the simplified severity weights (1 or 2 instead of the current range) will change how some violations affect percentile calculations. Carriers with borderline scores in those categories should understand how their current violations will map to the new methodology.

Turning operational data into an underwriter-ready story

The carriers winning in the two-fleet market are the ones who can present their operational data as a coherent narrative. Underwriters want to see that the data changes behavior, not just that the data exists. That means connecting telematics events to coaching records, maintenance schedules to PM compliance metrics, and driver training to scorecard improvement.

FleetOS is built for this problem. It consolidates TMS, telematics, maintenance, and safety data into a governed layer where operations, safety, and finance use the same definitions. The morning brief surfaces exceptions. The driver scorecards connect to coaching documentation. The maintenance view shows PM compliance alongside dispatch availability. When renewal time arrives, the data is already organized into the story underwriters want to hear.

The companion posts on telematics as the insurance baseline and fleet analytics for insurance positioning cover the mechanics in detail. The point here is that the two-fleet split is not random. It tracks data maturity. Carriers who govern their data and document their processes end up on the favorable side of the split.

Conclusion

The trucking insurance market is sorting carriers into two categories: those who can demonstrate operational discipline through data, and those who cannot. Underwriters are pulling CSA scores, OOS rates, maintenance evidence, telematics utilization, and coaching documentation before they quote. The carriers on the favorable side of the split—flat renewals, multiple options—are the ones who prepare that story in advance. The carriers on the unfavorable side—30-40% hikes, restricted access, non-renewal—are the ones who show up with loss runs and hope the numbers speak for themselves. The numbers do speak. The question is whether you have organized them to say what you want.

Frequently asked questions

Is the new SMS methodology already in effect?

No. As of early November 2026, the enhanced SMS methodology approved in November 2024 is not live. Carriers are still scored on the seven BASICs under SMS Methodology v3.21. FMCSA is expected to present proposals for industry comment in the coming weeks. Some industry sites have incorrectly reported the new rules are active—carriers should prepare without panicking.

What CSA metrics matter most to underwriters?

Underwriters focus on Unsafe Driving, Vehicle Maintenance, and HOS Compliance percentiles, along with driver and vehicle out-of-service rates. Trends matter as much as absolute numbers—a carrier with improving percentiles tells a better story than one with stable but high scores. The underlying violation data and inspection frequency also inform the risk profile.

How far in advance should we prepare for renewal?

Start at least 90 days before renewal. Use that time to audit SMS data, challenge any incorrect inspections through DataQs, review driver qualification files, and assess telematics utilization. The final 30 days should be about packaging the documentation, not discovering problems.

Can premiums change mid-policy?

Yes. Progressive's Peter Niro noted that premiums can shift mid-policy when operations change—adding drivers, vehicles, or routes alters the risk profile. Carriers should communicate operational changes to their broker and insurer to avoid surprises.

How does the Vehicle Maintenance split in the new SMS affect carriers?

The new methodology will create a separate Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed category for pre-trip defects documented by drivers. This means pre-trip inspection documentation becomes more important. Carriers should ensure drivers are properly documenting defects and that those records are retained and retrievable.

What separates a strong-fleet submission from a weak one?

A strong submission leads with the safety story: SMS trends, OOS rates, telematics utilization metrics, coaching documentation samples, maintenance evidence, and loss context. A weak submission is just ACORD forms and loss runs. The difference is whether the carrier has organized their operational data into the risk narrative underwriters evaluate.

HT

Haseeb Tariq

Co-Founder at Vyntrix Labs

Let's build something intelligent

Ready to automate the busywork and scale with AI?

Book a free discovery call and we'll map your highest-impact automation opportunities, no obligation, no jargon.