Commercial Auto Rates Are Cooling. Trucking's Excess Layer Isn't.

The Ivans Index for October 2026 shows U.S. commercial auto average premium renewal increases slowed to 2.80%, down from 3.29% in September. That number will appear in executive summaries and rate-filing justifications across the industry. It is also misleading if you run trucks.
Commercial auto is a composite line. The 2.80% average blends small-fleet garage policies, delivery vans, and for-hire long-haul trucking into a single figure. What it hides is that the trucking liability segment—especially the excess tower above the first $1M—remains under severe stress. While aggregate commercial auto results improve, trucking excess capacity is shrinking, per-mile costs are rising faster than primary, and the carriers who need that coverage most are paying the steepest price.
The headline number vs. the trucking reality
AM Best reported that commercial auto had its best underwriting performance since 2021 in 2025, with the mid-year 2026 loss ratio hitting the lowest point in five years. The net underwriting loss narrowed to $2.2 billion from $4.9 billion. That sounds like the hard market is softening.
But the improvement is not uniform. AM Best found auto liability—77% of net premiums written—still posted an underwriting loss exceeding $4.6 billion in 2025, with a combined ratio of 108.6. Physical damage, by contrast, achieved a combined ratio of 83.2 and generated more than $2 billion in underwriting profit. The line is improving because physical damage is subsidizing liability, not because liability losses are under control.
For trucking, liability is the dominant exposure. And within liability, the excess layers are where the pain concentrates.
Why the excess tower is different
The American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) released research in May 2026 detailing the rising costs of trucking liability insurance. Insurance Journal's November 9 feature summarized the findings: from 2021 to 2024, trucking liability premiums per mile rose 18.6% to 10.2 cents per mile, outpacing consumer inflation by 5.4 percentage points. At the same time, heavy-duty truck-involved crash rates fell 2.6% industry-wide.
The disconnect is severity, not frequency. Among ATRI respondents, per-mile liability losses rose by an average of 33.1% over the same period. Fewer crashes are costing more.
Excess liability coverage is absorbing the worst of it. ATRI found that per-mile premium costs for the $5–$10 million layer rose 34% to 1.58 cents, and for the $10–$15 million layer rose 45% to 1.05 cents. 'These increases in excess coverage expenses point to the role of rampant litigation in inflating claims costs,' ATRI noted.
| Layer | Per-Mile Cost (2024) | % Increase (2021–2024) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary liability | ~10.2 cents | +18.6% |
| $5M–$10M excess | 1.58 cents | +34% |
| $10M–$15M excess | 1.05 cents | +45% |
The pattern is clear: the higher you go in the tower, the faster costs are rising. Primary liability is expensive; excess is accelerating away from it.
Why severity keeps rising
Several forces are compounding excess-layer losses. First, social inflation continues. AM Best noted a growing share of claimants represented by attorneys, more aggressive plaintiff strategies, higher jury awards, and rising repair costs for cameras, sensors, and advanced driver-assistance systems. The average liability loss per claim climbed to $31,537 in 2025 from $28,771 in 2024.
Second, plaintiff strategies are expanding the target list. The U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II (May 2026) opened the door for heightened litigation exposure against freight brokers. Until that ruling, brokers defended themselves against negligent-hiring claims by arguing that federal preemption shielded them from state lawsuits for the carriers they selected. The Supreme Court unanimously rejected that defense, ruling that state claims involving motor-vehicle safety can apply to brokers.
Conor O'Leary, president of Shelly, Middlebrooks & O'Leary, told Insurance Journal: 'It's the first one where the trial bar has gone after effectively the shipper and said, "We want to extend liability beyond the trucker. We want to go to the freight forwarder, possibly even to the owner of the goods." They're just going up the chain, which is going to increase the cost for all consumers.'
That case will push brokers to vet carriers harder—and push more liability claims into the excess tower when a contracted carrier's limits are exhausted.
The tale of two fleets
Mark Gallagher, RPS transportation leader, described the current market split in Insurance Business: strong fleets are getting flat or roughly 5% renewals and multiple options, while weaker accounts face 30–40% hikes, fewer insurers, and restricted access. Underwriters are asking whether financial pressure is eroding maintenance spending or driver retention.
The Insurance Information Institute and Milliman forecast a U.S. commercial auto net combined ratio of 100.9 for 2026, indicating an underwriting loss, with the line expected to remain above 100 through 2028. Insurers cannot continue absorbing these losses uniformly. Segmentation is the response: favorable terms for accounts that demonstrate safety discipline, non-renewal or significant surcharging for accounts that do not.
ATRI's operating-cost data illustrates why financial pressure translates to underwriting risk. Average costs reached a record $2.336 per mile in 2025, up 3.4%, while repair and maintenance costs climbed 8.6%. Operating margins in truckload and refrigerated sectors sit below 1%. Insurers at WSIA cited concern that financial pressure is forcing carriers to cut corners—aging equipment without reinvestment, deferred maintenance, reduced driver training spend. Those cuts produce the warning signs underwriters hunt for.
What this means for 2027 renewals
The 2.80% Ivans headline will not help a trucking account that needs $5M or $10M excess capacity. Excess markets are pricing the severity they see, not the average across all commercial auto. The accounts getting relief are the ones with documented safety programs, clean loss runs, and evidence that their operations match their risk profile.
For carriers heading into 2027 renewals, the message is: the primary layer may stabilize, but the excess tower is where underwriting discipline is tightest. If your account has adverse experience in the excess layers, expect scrutiny. If you have a clean story to tell, the capacity is there—but you have to tell it.
The pre-renewal checklist for carriers
Brandon Wiseman, owner and president of Trucksafe Consulting, told Insurance Journal that too many fleets react after something terrible has happened. 'At that point, there's only so much you can do about those things if you haven't had the controls in place ahead of time to manage that risk,' he said. The checklist starts before the crash, not after.
Documented safety program
- Written policies and procedures for driver qualification, hours-of-service compliance, and fatigue management.
- Driver coaching records that connect telematics events to conversations, acknowledgments, and corrective actions.
- Continuous license monitoring—not just annual MVR pulls. A revoked or downgraded CDL between annual checks is a material exposure.
- Training documentation that shows ongoing investment, not just onboarding.
Clean loss runs with context
- Request loss runs 90 days before renewal and review for accuracy.
- Prepare narrative context for any significant claims: what happened, what changed afterward, and current status.
- If you have nuclear-verdict exposure, document the defense strategy and outcome.
Dashcam and telematics evidence
- Equipment coverage: how many trucks have cameras and telematics, and is the data being used?
- Event review process: who reviews critical events, how quickly, and what happens next?
- Data sharing: some insurers and programs offer pricing consideration when fleets share telematics data. Understand what you are sharing and what you get in return.
Maintenance records
- PM compliance rates by unit and overall fleet.
- Brake and tire inspection schedules, with documentation of findings and repairs.
- Out-of-service rate trends: are you above or below national average, and is the trend improving?
Broker-facing compliance packet
Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II means freight brokers will vet carriers more carefully. A carrier with a ready compliance packet—insurance certificates, safety summary, CSA/SMS scores, and operating authority documentation—will be easier to book and more attractive to brokers concerned about negligent-selection exposure.
Submission quality for the excess layer
- Lead with the safety story: SMS trends, OOS rates, telematics utilization, coaching documentation.
- Include maintenance evidence, not just equipment lists.
- Contextualize loss history: what drove any large claims and what operational changes followed.
- Show driver retention and training metrics—underwriters want to see process maturity.
For agencies writing trucking renewals
The tale of two fleets plays out at the submission level. A stack of ACORD forms and loss runs is no longer sufficient for accounts that need competitive excess capacity. The agencies winning capacity are the ones that translate carrier operations into the risk language underwriters speak.
HaulSure OS is built for this workflow—helping agencies assemble loss runs, COIs, ACORD apps, and clean submissions faster so the safety story reaches the underwriter instead of getting buried in a document pile. The goal is submission quality that differentiates a strong-fleet presentation from a commodity quote request.
For carriers, FleetOS consolidates TMS, telematics, maintenance, and safety data into a governed layer where operations, safety, and finance use the same definitions. When renewal time arrives, the evidence—PM compliance, coaching records, driver scorecards—is already organized into the story underwriters want to hear. The tool does not write the policy; the carrier's operations do. FleetOS makes that evidence retrievable.
Conclusion
The Ivans Index shows commercial auto cooling. That headline applies to the composite line, not to trucking's excess tower. ATRI data shows excess-layer costs rising faster than primary, driven by severity increases that lower crash rates have not offset. The Montgomery decision expands litigation targets. The combined ratio remains above 100, and insurers are segmenting aggressively.
For trucking accounts heading into 2027, the practical question is not whether the market is softening—it is whether your account presents the safety story that earns competitive terms. Documented programs, clean loss runs, telematics evidence, maintenance records, and broker-ready compliance packets are the difference between flat renewals and 30–40% hikes. The averages are cooling. The excess layer is not.
Frequently asked questions
Why are excess liability costs rising faster than primary?
Excess layers absorb the tail risk of large verdicts and settlements. Social inflation—more attorney representation, aggressive plaintiff strategies, and higher jury awards—disproportionately affects claims that breach primary limits. ATRI found the $5–$10M layer rose 34% and the $10–$15M layer rose 45% from 2021–2024, compared to 18.6% for primary liability.
What does Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II mean for carriers?
The May 2026 Supreme Court ruling allows state negligent-selection claims against freight brokers for the carriers they select. Brokers will vet carriers more carefully, favoring those with documented safety programs and clean records. Carriers without a ready compliance packet may find fewer booking opportunities.
How do I know if my account is 'strong fleet' or 'weak account'?
Strong accounts have clean SMS/CSA trends, OOS rates at or below national average, documented coaching and training programs, telematics utilization with evidence of behavioral response, and contextualized loss history. Weak accounts show deteriorating metrics, gaps in documentation, deferred maintenance, high driver turnover, or late claims reporting. Underwriters segment accordingly.
What is the combined ratio forecast for commercial auto?
The Insurance Information Institute and Milliman forecast a U.S. commercial auto net combined ratio of 100.9 for 2026, indicating an underwriting loss. The line is expected to remain above 100 through 2028. Improvement in physical damage is offsetting some liability losses, but liability—the dominant trucking exposure—remains unprofitable.
Should I raise my deductible to save on premiums?
RPS's Mark Gallagher cautions that a larger deductible may offer immediate premium relief, but the operator's ability to absorb future losses matters. Larger fleets with experienced risk management teams are better equipped to handle that trade-off. For smaller fleets, the potential volatility can become financially burdensome if claims frequency or severity worsens.
When should I start preparing for my renewal?
At least 90 days before renewal. Use that time to audit SMS data, challenge incorrect inspections through DataQs, review driver qualification files, assess telematics utilization, and compile maintenance records. The final 30 days should be about packaging the documentation, not discovering problems.
Haseeb Tariq
Co-Founder at Vyntrix Labs
Keep reading

Tale of Two Fleets: How Underwriters Read Your CSA Data Before a Trucking Insurance Renewal
The trucking insurance market is splitting: fleets with strong safety records see flat or modest renewals, while weaker accounts face 30-40% hikes and restricted access. Here is what underwriters actually pull, how to prepare, and what the pending SMS changes mean for your next renewal.
Haseeb Tariq
Co-Founder

Telematics Is Now the Baseline for Commercial Trucking Insurance
Insurers no longer reward carriers for simply installing ELDs, cameras, and telematics. They underwrite based on how fleets use the data: documented coaching, safety culture, and risk-score improvement over time. Here is what carriers need to understand about the shift.
Ashir Haroon
CEO

Fleet Analytics for Trucking Carriers: The Data That Now Prices Your Insurance
Carrier-side analytics—TMS, telematics, maintenance, and claims data—is becoming the credit score for insurance rates and shipper qualification. How carriers should turn scorecards, coaching records, and governed CPM data into renewal leverage.
Ashir Haroon
CEO