The Telematics-to-Shop Gap: Why Half of Trucking Fleets Still Can't See Real Cost Per Mile

Your ELD knows exactly where your trucks are. Your telematics platform tracks hard braking, speeding, and HOS compliance. Safety has never been more visible. But ask most fleet owners what it actually costs to run a truck per mile—broken down by fuel, maintenance, and downtime—and the answer usually involves a spreadsheet, a guess, and a prayer.
The American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) quantified this disconnect in September 2026. Their report, "From Data to Decisions: Trucking's Use of Telematics Data to Improve Performance," surveyed 111 motor carriers alongside six major telematics providers, evaluating 44 distinct KPIs. The headline: trucking has broadly adopted telematics for safety management, but many fleets have not yet moved into telematics utilization for maintenance and operational performance management.
The numbers behind the gap
ATRI found that 48% of surveyed carriers do not integrate their telematics data with maintenance management software. These fleets (median 73 trucks, middle range 21–320 units) capture driving events and location but leave that data disconnected from the shop floor. Another 43% do integrate the systems (median 101 trucks), and 10% use their telematics or fleet management platform itself for maintenance tracking.
The TMS picture is similarly fragmented. Nearly one in three carriers never connect telematics to their transportation management system, meaning fuel burn, location, and hours data don't reconcile with loads, lanes, and revenue.
| Integration Status | Percentage of Fleets | Median Fleet Size |
|---|---|---|
| Not integrated | 48% | 73 trucks |
| Integrated | 43% | 101 trucks |
| Telematics/FMS used for maintenance | 10% | — |
Why maintenance KPIs go unused
The ATRI study ranked KPIs by both importance (how critical carriers rate them) and adoption (how many actually track them). The gap between those two numbers reveals where fleets are leaving value on the table.
- PM scheduling: importance 3.97/5, but used by only 77.5%
- Missed preventive maintenance: importance 3.89/5, used by 66.7%
- Defect/fault diagnostics: importance 3.84/5, used by 73%
- Tire and brake health: tracked by only 52.3% of fleets
- Vehicle downtime predictions: tracked by 49.5%
- Cost per mile: consistently listed as underused
- Rollover risk indicators: underused across the sample
The pattern is clear. Safety KPIs—hard braking, speeding, HOS violations—are tracked because they have immediate regulatory and underwriting consequences. Maintenance KPIs require connecting telematics to shop systems, which requires IT work many small and mid-size fleets lack the bandwidth to complete.
The barriers: data overload, limited IT, tight margins
ATRI identified three recurring obstacles. First, data overload: telematics platforms generate thousands of events per day, and without a governed analytics layer, the signal drowns in noise. Second, limited IT resources at small fleets: the median non-integrated fleet is 73 trucks, a size where a dedicated systems administrator is rare. Third, financial constraints: rising costs across fuel, insurance, and parts tempt fleets to defer not just physical maintenance but also the software integrations that would surface problems earlier.
These barriers compound each other. When IT capacity is limited, data overload becomes paralyzing. When margins are tight, the integration project that could reveal cost-saving opportunities looks like an expense, not an investment.
The real-world consequence: brake systems at Roadcheck
Deferred maintenance is not an abstract risk. CVSA's 2026 International Roadcheck found brake systems as the top vehicle out-of-service violation, with 3,379 violations. Nineteen percent of vehicles inspected were placed out of service. Some of those OOS events were unpredictable failures. Many were not—they were missed PMs, ignored fault codes, and tire or brake health that telematics could have flagged weeks earlier if anyone were watching.
An OOS violation is more than a fine. It's a stranded load, a service failure, a CSA score hit, and—at renewal—a data point that underwriters will ask about. The connection from unintegrated telematics to insurance cost runs through exactly this kind of preventable event.
What integrated data actually looks like
When telematics, maintenance, and TMS data flow into a single governed layer, the fleet gains capabilities that spreadsheets cannot replicate:
- Cost per mile by truck, driver, customer, and lane—not a fleet average, but a real number with identifiable variance.
- PM compliance tied to miles and hours, not calendar estimates.
- Fault codes that surface before dispatch clears a unit for a load.
- Fuel efficiency correlated with driver behavior, route, and payload—enabling coaching that moves the needle.
- Downtime predictions based on repair history and real-time diagnostics.
The operational benefit is exception-first management: dispatch sees which units are at risk, safety sees which drivers need coaching, and maintenance sees which faults are trending toward failure. The underwriting benefit is a documented, data-mature operation that presents a coherent story at renewal—scorecard trends, maintenance discipline, and CPM control.
The AI insight layer: what's emerging
As fleets struggle to extract value from raw telematics, a new generation of AI-powered analytics layers is emerging to sit on top of existing systems rather than replace them.
Fleetworthy's RADAR platform identifies toll leakage—transponder mismatches, incorrect vehicle classes, duplicate charges—across toll transactions that fleets otherwise accept as correct. PrePass Intelligence, including its Forecast CSA tool, applies predictive analytics to inspection data and routing decisions. At IAA Transportation 2026, Webfleet previewed an AI Advisor tool designed to surface actionable recommendations from telematics data rather than dump raw alerts on dispatchers.
The common thread: these tools assume the telematics data exists but recognize that fleets lack the time, IT staff, or analytics expertise to act on it. The AI layer is a force multiplier for small and mid-size carriers who cannot build a data team but can subscribe to one.
Deadhead, fuel, and the optimization opportunity
The same integration gap affects load planning. Optimal Dynamics reported in a November 2026 webinar that carriers using their optimization platform reduced deadhead by 4–8%. That reduction comes from connecting load data, driver HOS, equipment availability, and location—the same data streams ATRI found disconnected in half of fleets.
Empty miles are the most visible symptom, but fuel and detention are close behind. Without integrated data, detention goes untracked (or tracked in a separate spreadsheet that no one reconciles). Fuel cost per mile varies by driver, route, and speed, but the variance is invisible until telematics and fuel-card data land in the same view. These are the operational problems that data integration solves—and that remain unsolved when telematics stays siloed for safety only.
A step-by-step plan for small and mid-size fleets
Closing the telematics-to-shop gap does not require a six-figure ERP project. Most fleets already own the data; they need a governed layer to connect it. Here is a practical sequence:
- Audit your current state. List every system that captures operational data: ELD/telematics, TMS, maintenance/CMMS, fuel cards, IFTA. Note which systems export data, which have APIs, and which are manual entry.
- Define cost per mile. Agree on a formula with finance and operations. Document the inputs (fuel, maintenance, insurance allocation, depreciation, driver pay) and the denominator (revenue miles, loaded miles, total miles). Until this definition exists, every CPM conversation is a debate.
- Start with one integration. If telematics and TMS are disconnected, connect them first—that ties miles and hours to loads. If telematics and maintenance are disconnected, connect them—that ties fault codes and PM intervals to dispatch decisions.
- Surface exceptions, not dashboards. Build a daily or weekly exception list: units with open downing work orders, drivers below scorecard threshold, loads off plan. The goal is action, not reporting.
- Track a single maintenance KPI end to end. Pick PM compliance or missed-PM rate. Measure it monthly. When it improves, expand to tire health, brake health, and fault-code response time.
- Present the data at renewal. Package the integration progress—scorecard trends, PM compliance, CPM trajectory—for your broker and underwriter. Even partial data maturity differentiates you from carriers who show up with only loss runs.
The sequence is designed to produce visible wins before demanding significant capital. Each step builds the data foundation for the next.
Insurance renewal: where integration pays off
Underwriters increasingly evaluate carriers on data maturity, not just loss history. The companion posts on telematics as the insurance baseline and fleet analytics for insurance rates cover the shift in detail. The short version: a carrier that can show integrated data—scorecards, coaching records, maintenance discipline, CPM control—presents a lower risk than one with the same hardware and no process around the data.
The tale of two fleets illustrates the split. Fleets with strong safety records and documented programs see stable renewals. Fleets with weak CSA data and no evidence of process improvement face premium hikes and capacity restrictions. Integration is not just an operational investment; it is risk positioning.
Where FleetOS fits
FleetOS is the governed data layer we build for motor carriers. It connects TMS, telematics, maintenance, and fuel into a single operating picture: cost per mile that finance and operations agree on, exception queues that surface problems before dispatch, driver scorecards that link to coaching, and export packages for insurance and shipper qualification. The goal is to close the telematics-to-shop gap for fleets that don't have—and don't want to build—a dedicated data team.
The operational problems carriers face—fragmented systems, undefined metrics, manual reconciliation—are covered in the problems every fleet faces. The lifecycle from tender to settlement, and where data falls out of the chain, is mapped in how carriers run a haul. FleetOS is designed to bridge those gaps without replacing the TMS, ELD, or CMMS a fleet already runs.
Conclusion
Trucking has solved the telematics adoption problem. The hardware is in place. The data is flowing. What's missing—for nearly half of fleets—is the connection from that data to maintenance, cost, and operational decisions. The telematics-to-shop gap explains why carriers with modern technology still manage by spreadsheet and gut feel: the data exists, but it doesn't talk to the shop, the TMS, or the finance team.
Closing the gap is not a technology project for next year. It is a competitive necessity now. Underwriters are differentiating on data maturity. Shippers are auditing carrier safety programs. AI tools are emerging to extract value that manual review cannot. The fleets that integrate telematics with maintenance and operations will see their cost per mile, present a better risk profile, and operate with fewer surprises. The ones that don't will keep guessing—and keep paying for it.
Frequently asked questions
Why is telematics adoption high for safety but not maintenance?
Safety KPIs—hard braking, speeding, HOS compliance—carry immediate regulatory and insurance consequences. Maintenance KPIs require integrating telematics with shop software, which demands IT resources many small and mid-size fleets lack. The ATRI study found data overload, limited IT capacity, and financial constraints as the primary barriers.
What is the cost of not integrating telematics with maintenance?
The cost shows up as preventable breakdowns, missed PMs that become OOS violations, fuel variance no one can explain, and a CPM number that finance and operations define differently. At renewal, it means showing up with only loss runs while competitors present documented safety programs and maintenance discipline.
Which maintenance KPIs should we start tracking first?
PM compliance and missed-PM rate are the highest-impact starting points—ATRI found they are rated highly important but tracked by only 66–77% of fleets. From there, add tire and brake health (tracked by 52% of fleets) and fault-code diagnostics. These directly affect OOS risk and equipment availability.
Do we need to replace our TMS or maintenance software to integrate?
Usually not. Most integration projects connect existing systems through APIs or data exports. The missing piece is a governed analytics layer that consolidates the data, applies consistent definitions, and surfaces exceptions. That layer sits on top of the TMS, ELD, and CMMS—not in place of them.
How does integrated data help at insurance renewal?
Underwriters increasingly evaluate data maturity alongside loss history. A carrier that can present driver scorecards, coaching documentation, PM compliance rates, and CPM trends demonstrates operational discipline. That data differentiates you from carriers with similar loss records but no process around their telematics investment.
What are AI insight layers, and do small fleets need them?
AI insight layers—like Fleetworthy RADAR for toll leakage or Webfleet's AI Advisor for telematics recommendations—analyze data that already exists in fleet systems and surface actionable insights without requiring a dedicated data team. For small and mid-size fleets that lack IT bandwidth, these tools act as a force multiplier: you subscribe to analytics capacity instead of building it.
Haseeb Tariq
Co-Founder at Vyntrix Labs
Keep reading

Fleet Analytics for Trucking Carriers: The Data That Now Prices Your Insurance
Carrier-side analytics—TMS, telematics, maintenance, and claims data—is becoming the credit score for insurance rates and shipper qualification. How carriers should turn scorecards, coaching records, and governed CPM data into renewal leverage.
Ashir Haroon
CEO

Telematics Is Now the Baseline for Commercial Trucking Insurance
Insurers no longer reward carriers for simply installing ELDs, cameras, and telematics. They underwrite based on how fleets use the data: documented coaching, safety culture, and risk-score improvement over time. Here is what carriers need to understand about the shift.
Ashir Haroon
CEO

Tale of Two Fleets: How Underwriters Read Your CSA Data Before a Trucking Insurance Renewal
The trucking insurance market is splitting: fleets with strong safety records see flat or modest renewals, while weaker accounts face 30-40% hikes and restricted access. Here is what underwriters actually pull, how to prepare, and what the pending SMS changes mean for your next renewal.
Haseeb Tariq
Co-Founder